27th March 2025
A COCKTAIL OF VIOLENCE AND GLAMOUR in 1920’s CHICAGO

1920s Chicago was one of the most exciting cities in the Western world where glamour, crime, music and industry produced a progressive and legendary era. Some of the world’s best loved musicals, like ‘Bugsy Malone’ and ‘Chicago’ (soon to be showing in our home city of Truro, at the Hall for Cornwall) are based on true stories from that time.
THE LURE OF CHICAGO
Chicago was the centre of the great jazz age. Mighty talents like Louis Armstrong and King Oliver played at the Grand Terrace Café. Chicago’s skyline soared with famous buildings like the neo-Gothic Tribune Tower, and hometown baseball teams like the Chicago Cubs garnered huge and devoted followings. The lakeside city’s stockyards and railroads, together with the thriving manufacturing and meatpacking industries, meant Chicago was an industrial powerhouse and a key economic and cultural centre.
An influx of African-American culture from the south also influenced the music and dance bring joyful dances like the Charleston. At the centre of this Roaring Twenties storm was gangster Alphonse Capone and his partnership with the bewitching temptress: Alcohol.
CHICAGO and AL CAPONE
Al Capone exploded out of his native New York in the early 1920s, into South Chicago “southside mob” and then ultimately taking overall control of Chicago’s criminal underworld. His ruthless, violent control meant ‘Scarface’ Capone was soon leading the ‘Chicago Outfit’ gang. Through his racketeering, gambling and bootlegging Capone and his wife swiftly became billionaires by today’s standards.
PROHIBITION in CHICAGO
Men like Capone saw the National Prohibition Act of 1920 (forbidding the manufacture, selling or transporting of alcohol) as a golden opportunity. Legislation brought about by the Anti-Saloon League (ASL) and various Christian denominations was blind to something that blindingly obvious to Capone: forbidden fruit is the sweetest!
The prohibition of alcohol sales guaranteed a thirst for booze and fun times. In an era when getting your hands on a bottle of drink was the holy grail, using a password to open musty cellar doors into a shimmering jazz-filled speakeasy buried deep in a hotel basement was irresistibly exciting. The Friar’s Inn, the Green Mill Jazz Club and the Milk Room were speakeasies famous for serving booze and for bringing jazz, gangsters, guns, girls and gin all together under one roof.
UNHAPPY VALENTINE’S DAY
Controlling the majority of illegal alcohol distribution in Prohibition-era Chicago, Capone’s bribery silenced city officials and police, and his violence eliminated rivals. By 1929 Capone had seven rival gang members gunned down in the famous St Valentine’s Day Massacre.
But Capone had a heart too. During the Great Depression, frustrated by the lack of help for the unemployed, he donated money to charity and earned a reputation as a modern Robin Hood for running a soup-kitchen serving up 3 hot square meals a day to around 1-2,000 Chicagoans, no questions asked. The Chicago Evening Press was told, “He couldn’t stand to see those poor devils starving.”
There are no tales of Capone’s ‘cocktail kitchens’, serving ‘whiskey’ breakfasts or gin and tonics for lunch, but if he had we like to think he’d have served up some familiar Chicago cocktails such as:
CHICAGO’S SOUTH SIDE
This cocktail classic said to have originated in early 20th Century Chicago, was apparently named after the South Side of the city. The story goes that the Chicago north side mob moved into Gin, so Capone’s South side gang following the competition also moved into gin developing the South Side Cocktail at the same time. Years later the New York Club21 popularised the cocktail (Chronology open to debate but it makes a great story)
INGREDIENTS:
- 60ml Rosemullion dry gin
- 30ml Lemon Juice (Sweeter: 25ml)
- 30ml Sugar Syrup (Sweeter: 35ml)
- 5-8 Mint leaves
- Garnish: Sprig of mint
METHOD:
- Add Mint leaves & Lemon Juice to a shaker and muddle until the Mint is bruised.
- Add Gin & Sugar Syrup and shake on ice.
- Fine strain to a chilled short tumbler glass and add ice.
- Garnish with a sprig of mint.

CHICAGO’S SOUTH SIDE BATCH RECIPE (Makes 8 120ml servings)
INGREDIENTS:
- 480ml Rosemullion Dry Gin*
- 240ml Lemon Juice
- 240ml Sugar Syrup
- Fresh mint
METHOD:
- Combine liquids to a sterilised litre bottle (i.e. a kilner style bottle).
- Pour 120ml into a shaker and add 5-6 mint leaves.
- Muddle until mint is bruised.
- Shake on ice.
- Fine strain to a chilled short tumbler glass and add ice.
- Garnish with a sprig of mint.
- *Our Rosemullion Distillery Dry Gin has lemon peel in it, pairing beautifully with the citrus juice in the drink.

AN OLD FASHIONED CHICAGO?
Beginning as a simple whisky cocktail from around the 1800s, the Old Fashioned grew in popularity. The Prohibition Era brought in the addition of orange peel, probably to mask the brutality of the bootleg ‘whiskey’ taste. Served in a lowball glass, this is one of life’s great classic tastes.
INGREDIENTS:
- 60 ml of Rosemullion Distillery whisky or as the Americans call it, ‘whiskey’.
- 2tsp sugar syrup or 1 tsp of granulated sugar
- Splash of water
- 1 – 2dashes bitters depending on your preference
- 1slice orange
- A few ice cubes
- 1 Maraschino cherry (optional!)
METHOD:
- First place the syrup or sugar, water and bitters into a lowball tumbler.
- Mix if using granulated until the sugar dissolves
- Fill the glass with ice
- Pour in the whisky and stir.
- Add a splash of soda water if you like and mix.
- Garnish with the orange and cherry.
COHASSET PUNCH
Created back in 1899 “to surpass anything ever before imbibed by a living soul” the Cohasset Punch is Chicago’s signature cocktail. A telegrammed request was sent by Chicago saloon owner and liquor dealer Lewis A. Williams to his business partner Tom Newman back in Chicago to create a rum-based drink. Williams wanted to impress fellow visitors on a lazy summer stay at Cohasset, (Massachusetts) the estate of close family friends that Williams was staying with.
Within 24 hours Williams’ partner, Newman had placed a cask of punch on a railcar bound for Massachusetts. On tasting it the visitors proclaimed Newman ‘the king of blenders’. Named Cohasset in honour of the estate, it continues to be produced to this day.
If you want to recreate delicious Chicago cocktail, but don’t have access to the bottle of drink that is sold to this day as Cohasset Punch, then we suggest the following recipe:
INGREDIENTS
- ½ Lemon cut into pieces
- 60 ml Gold rum
- 60 ml Sweet Vermouth
- A dash of orange bitters
- 5 ml rich simple syrup.
- 1 slice of canned peach or peach soaked in brandy.
METHOD
- Muddle the lemon in a mixing glass.
- Add the amber rum, sweet vermouth, simple syrup and orange bitters.
- Then stir and strain into large champagne coupe with slice of brandied or canned peach.
CHICAGO NAILS AL CAPONE
The US government eventually ‘got their mitts’ on Capone. Despite having personally murdered at least four people and ordered the murders of many more, Capone was finally nailed for tax evasion. In 1931, convicted and sentenced to 11 years in prison, he began serving time in the infamous island prison of Alcatraz.
Capone’s legacy is inseparable from Chicago’s history so if you want a taste of those wild, glamorous, corrupt and violent times then make yourself an Old Fashioned and sit comfortably to enjoy ‘Chicago’ whether on screen or in theatres now.
ENDS











